Gabriel's horn holds a finite volume and needs infinite paint

Spin y = 1/x about the x-axis from 1 to infinity: the volume integral is π, the area integral is not.

Calculus · Level: Classic result · Updated on 2026-11-10

Rotate the hyperbola y = 1/x about the x-axis, starting at x = 1 and going on for ever, and you get a trumpet that is infinitely long. Its volume is π∫₁^∞ dx/x², which converges to exactly π. The first link is that integral cut off at a million, and the panel prints 3.141589512 — π short by π times a millionth, which is what cutting the horn at x = a leaves behind: the volume out to a is π(1 − 1/a). The third link prints π itself, 3.1415926535898, so the difference between the finite trumpet and its first million units is visible in the sixth decimal place and nowhere after it.

The surface is another matter. Its area is 2π∫₁^∞ (1/x)√(1 + 1/x⁴) dx, and since the square root is never below 1 the area is at least 2π∫ dx/x, which diverges. The second link integrates 1/x from 1 to a million anyway and prints 13.815510558 — the logarithm of a million — and the point of printing it is that the logarithm is the slowest thing here that still has no limit. Fill the horn and you use π cubic units of paint; paint the inside and each unit of length costs more brush than the last, for ever. The usual dismissal is correct and worth saying: a real coat of paint has thickness, so it cannot cover a surface whose remaining length runs out to infinity in the idealised sense, and the paradox is a disagreement between two integrals with different powers of 1/x in them, not a fact about tins.

Answer

3.141589512

How to read it

The integral panel on π/x² from 1 to 1 000 000, which is π minus a millionth of π. The second link is ∫₁^10⁶ dx/x, the area side that will not converge.

Source

Evangelista Torricelli, 1641, on the solid of revolution of y = 1/x for x ≥ 1, which has finite volume and infinite surface area; Hobbes attacked the result and Wallis defended it

Work it in the calculator

These links open the right calculator with this problem's numbers already typed in. The line above is what the screen should show — check it yourself.

This is an independent third-party tool site. It is not affiliated with, sponsored by, or authorised by Casio, Texas Instruments or their distributors. Model names and product names are trademarks of their respective owners and appear here only to identify devices.

The keystroke sequences in these manuals were written from this site's own layout data — the same data the online calculator renders — plus publicly available product facts. Specifications and regional configurations are confirmed against the physical device and the manufacturer's most recent material.