One US gallon converts to 3.785411784 L, and that is not a survey result with error bars — it is arithmetic. The gallon is defined as 231 cubic inches, the inch is defined as 2.54 cm, so 231 × 2.54³ cm³ = 3785.411784 cm³ exactly, and the litre is 1000 cm³. Run the conversion by the long route and the card prints the same 3.785411784 L for 231 in³, which is the check that the nine decimals came from the definition rather than from a measuring cup.
The imperial gallon is a different animal defined a different way: 4.54609 L, from the older 10 pounds of water, and it survives in the UK's measurements to this day. One cubic inch is 0.016387064 L exactly — nine decimals again, all of them inherited from 2.54³. Two countries, two gallons, one inch, and every digit here fixed by agreement rather than by measurement.
Answer
3.785411784 L
How to read it
The converter's own line. The same figure comes out of 231 in³ → L, which is the definition the gallon actually rests on.
Source
The US gallon is defined as exactly 231 cubic inches; with 1 in = 2.54 cm exactly (International Yard and Pound Agreement, 1959) the litre figure follows to the last digit
Work it in the calculator
These links open the right calculator with this problem's numbers already typed in. The line above is what the screen should show — check it yourself.