A 99 % test on a 1-in-1000 disease gives 0.09016393442623

Nine positives in ten are false, and the reason is one line of arithmetic nobody expects.

Statistics and data · Level: Classic result · Updated on 2026-11-10

Take a disease one person in a thousand has, and a test that flags 99% of the sick and 1% of the healthy. The chance that someone picked up by the test is actually sick is 0.99 × 0.001 in the numerator, over 0.99 × 0.001 + 0.01 × 0.999 in the denominator, and the workbench answers 0.09016393442623. A 99% accurate test, and nine out of ten flagged people are wrong.

The two terms explain it if you look at their sizes: true positives arrive at 9.9⋅10−4 per person, false positives at 0.00999 — ten times the stream. The same arithmetic in natural frequencies is easier on the intuition: screen a thousand people, one is ill and is caught with probability 0.99, while 9.99 of the 999 healthy ones are flagged anyway. Nothing about the test is inaccurate; what is scarce is the disease, and a 1% error rate applied to a healthy population swamps a 99% hit rate applied to a sick one.

Answer

0.09016393442623

How to read it

The positive predictive value on the workbench. The two following links are its numerator and the false-positive term, which is the larger of the two.

Source

Positive predictive value = sensitivity·prevalence / (sensitivity·prevalence + false-positive-rate·(1 − prevalence)); base-rate neglect was demonstrated in Kahneman and Tversky's taxi-cab problem and the screening version popularised by Gerd Gigerenzer

Work it in the calculator

These links open the right calculator with this problem's numbers already typed in. The line above is what the screen should show — check it yourself.

This is an independent third-party tool site. It is not affiliated with, sponsored by, or authorised by Casio, Texas Instruments or their distributors. Model names and product names are trademarks of their respective owners and appear here only to identify devices.

The keystroke sequences in these manuals were written from this site's own layout data — the same data the online calculator renders — plus publicly available product facts. Specifications and regional configurations are confirmed against the physical device and the manufacturer's most recent material.